Effect of cold and heat therapies on pain relief in patients with delayed onset muscle soreness: A network meta-analysis
Keywords:network meta-analysis, cold therapy, heat therapy, delayed onset muscle soreness
Objective: To comprehensively compare the effectiveness of cold and heat therapies for delayed onset muscle soreness using network meta-analysis.
Methods: Eight Chinese and English databases were searched from date of establishment of the database to 31 May 2021. Cochrane risk-of-bias tool was used to analyse the included randomized controlled trials. Potential papers were screened for eligibility, and data were extracted by 2 independent researchers.
Results: A total of 59 studies involving 1,367 patients were eligible for this study. Ten interventions were examined: contrast water therapy, phase change material, the novel modality of cryotherapy, cold-water immersion, hot/warm-water immersion, cold pack, hot pack, ice massage, ultrasound, and passive recovery. Network meta-analysis results showed that: (i) within 24 h after exercise, hot pack was the most effective for pain relief, followed by contrast water therapy; (ii) within 48 h, the ranking was hot pack, followed by the novel modality of cryotherapy; and (iii) over 48 h post-exercise, the effect of the novel modality of cryotherapy ranked first.
Conclusion: Due to the limited quality of the included studies, further well-designed research is needed to draw firm conclusions about the effectiveness of cold and heat therapies for delayed onset muscle soreness.
The effects of different methods of cold and heat
therapy on pain in patients with delayed onset muscle soreness are debated, and there is uncertainty regarding the most effective of these therapies. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effects of different cold and heat treatments on pain in patients with delayed onset muscle soreness. Using network meta-analysis and ranking, it was found that, within 48 h post-exercise, use of hot-pack was superior to other interventions, whereas, over 48 h post-exercise, cryotherapy was the optimal intervention for pain relief in patients with delayed onset muscle soreness.
Armstrong RB. Mechanisms of exercise-induced delayed onset muscular soreness: a brief review. Med Sci Sports Exerc 1984; 16: 529-538.
Cleak MJ, Eston RG. Delayed onset muscle soreness: mechanisms and management. J Sports 1992; 10: 325-341.
Lightfoot TJ, Char D, McDermott J, Goya C. Immediate postexercise massage does not attenuate delayed onset muscle soreness. J Strength Cond Res 1997; 11: 119-124.
Cheung K, Hume P, Maxwell L. Delayed onset muscle soreness: treatment strategies and performance factors. Sports Med 2003; 33: 145-164.
Zhao L. Study on the pathogenesis and prevention of delayed muscle soreness. Wushu Studies 2017; 2: 136-139.
Connolly DA, Sayers SP, McHugh MP. Treatment and prevention of delayed onset muscle soreness. J Strength Cond Res 2003; 17: 197-208.
Malmir K, Ghotbi N, Mir SM, Moradi B. Comparing effects of cryotherapy and transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation on signs and symptoms of delayed onset muscle soreness in amateur athletes. Open Pain J 2017; 10: 73-80.
Guilhem G, Hug F, Couturier A, Regnault S, Bournat L, Filliard JR, et al. Effects of air-pulsed cryotherapy on neuromuscular recovery subsequent to exercise-induced muscle damage. Am J Sports Med 2013; 41: 1942-1951.
Costello JT, Algar LA, Donnelly AE. Effects of whole-body cryotherapy (-110 degrees C) on proprioception and indices of muscle damage. Scand J Med Sci Sports 2012; 22: 190-198.
Jinnah AH, Luo TD, Mendias C, Freehill M. Cryotherapy duration is critical in short-term recovery of athletes: a systematic review. J ISAKOS 2019; 4: 131-136.
Petrofsky JS, Khowailed IA, Lee H, Berk L, Bains GS, Akerkar S, et al. Cold vs. heat after exercise - is there a clear winner for muscle soreness. J Strength Cond Res 2015; 29: 3245-3252.
Hohenauer E, Taeymans J, Baeyens JP, Clarys P, Clijsen R. The effect of post-exercise cryotherapy on recovery characteristics: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One 2015; 10: e0139028.
Hutton B, Salanti G, Caldwell DM, Chaimani A, Schmid CH, Cameron C, et al. The PRISMA extension statement for reporting of systematic reviews incorporating network meta-analyses of health care interventions: checklist and explanations. Ann Intern Med 2015; 162: 777-784.
Higgins JP, Altman DG. Assessing risk of bias in included studies. Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions. Cochrane book series 2008; 187-241. [Cited 2021 Jun 15]. Available from: https://doi.org/10.1002/9780470712184.ch8.
Salanti G, Ades AE, Ioannidis JP. Graphical methods and numerical summaries for presenting results from multiple-treatment meta-analysis: an overview and tutorial. J Clin Epidemiol 2011; 64: 163-171.
Yanagisawa O, Niitsu M, Yoshioka H, Goto K, Kudo H, Itai Y. The use of magnetic resonance imaging to evaluate the effects of cooling on skeletal muscle after strenuous exercise. Eur J Appl Physiol 2003; 89: 53-62.
Wilson LJ, Dimitriou L, Hills FA, Gondek MB, Cockburn E. Whole body cryotherapy, cold water immersion, or a placebo following resistance exercise: a case of mind over matter? . Eur J Appl Physiol 2019; 119: 135-147.
Wilson LJ, Cockburn E, Paice K, Sinclair S, Faki T, Hills FA, et al. Recovery following a marathon: a comparison of cold water immersion, whole body cryotherapy and a placebo control. Eur J Appl Physiol 2017; 118: 153-163.
Vieira A, Siqueira AF, Ferreira-Junior JB, do Carmo J, Durigan JL, Blazevich A, et al. The effect of water temperature during cold-water immersion on recovery from exercise-induced muscle damage. Int J Sports Med 2016; 37: 937-943.
Vaile JM, Gill ND, Blazevich AJ. The effect of contrast water therapy on symptoms of delayed onset muscle soreness. J Strength Cond Res 2007; 21: 697-702.
Vaile J, Halson S, Gill N, Dawson B. Effect of hydrotherapy on the signs and symptoms of delayed onset muscle soreness. Eur J Appl Physiol 2008; 102: 447-455.
Skurvydas A, Sipaviciene S, Krutulyte G, Gailiuniene A, Stasiulis A, Mamkus G, et al. Cooling leg muscles affects dynamics of indirect indicators of skeletal muscle damage. J Back Musculoskelet Rehabil 2006; 19: 141-151.
Siqueira AF, Vieira A, Bottaro M, Ferreira-Junior JB, Nobrega OT, de Souza VC, et al. Multiple cold-water immersions attenuate muscle damage but not alter systemic inflammation and muscle function recovery: a parallel randomized controlled trial. Sci Rep 2018; 8: 10961.
Sellwood KL, Brukner P, Williams D, Nicol A, Hinman R. Ice-water immersion and delayed-onset muscle soreness: a randomised controlled trial. Br J Sports Med 2007; 41: 392-397.
Pointon M, Duffield R, Cannon J, Marino FE. Cold application for neuromuscular recovery following intense lower-body exercise. Eur J Appl Physiol 2011; 111: 2977-2986.
Petrofsky JS, Laymon M, Berk L, Al-Nakhli HH, Banh A, Eisentrout A, et al. Pilot study: physiological evidence that heat reduces pain and muscle damage in delayed-onset muscle soreness. Clin Pract 2012; 9: 639-650.
Petrofsky J, Berk L, Bains G, Khowailed IA, Lee H, Laymon M. The efficacy of sustained heat treatment on delayed-onset muscle soreness. Clin J Sport Med 2017; 27: 329-337.
Naugle KE, Parr JJ, Chang S, Naugle KM. Active gaming as pain relief following induced muscle soreness in a college-aged population. Athl Train Sports Health Care 2017; 9: 225-232.
Machado AF, Almeida AC, Micheletti JK, Vanderlei FM, Tribst MF, Netto Junior J, et al. Dosages of cold-water immersion post exercise on functional and clinical responses: a randomized controlled trial. Scand J Med Sci Sports 2017; 27: 1356-1363.
Lindsay A, Carr S, Cross S, Petersen C, Lewis JG, Gieseg SP. The physiological response to cold-water immersion following a mixed martial arts training session. Appl Physiol Nutr Metab 2017; 42: 529-536.
Leeder JD, van Someren KA, Bell PG, Spence JR, Jewell AP, Gaze D, et al. Effects of seated and standing cold water immersion on recovery from repeated sprinting. J Sports Sci 2015; 33: 1544-1552.
Kwiecien SY, O'Hara DJ, McHugh MP, Howatson G. Prolonged cooling with phase change material enhances recovery and does not affect the subsequent repeated bout effect following exercise. Eur J Appl Physiol 2020; 120: 413-423.
Kwiecien SY, McHugh MP, Howatson G. The efficacy of cooling with phase change material for the treatment of exercise-induced muscle damage: pilot study. J Sports Sci 2018; 36: 407-413.
Kuligowski LA, Lephart SM, Giannantonio FP, Blanc RO. Effect of whirlpool therapy on the signs and symptoms of delayed-onset muscle soreness. J Athl Train 1998; 33: 222-228.
Jakeman JR, Macrae R, Eston R. A single 10-min bout of cold-water immersion therapy after strenuous plyometric exercise has no beneficial effect on recovery from the symptoms of exercise-induced muscle damage. Ergonomics 2009; 52: 456-460.
Crowther F, Sealey R, Crowe M, Edwards A, Halson S. Influence of recovery strategies upon performance and perceptions following fatiguing exercise: a randomized controlled trial. BMC Sports Sci Med Rehabil. 2017; 9: 25.
Ingram J, Dawson B, Goodman C, Wallman K, Beilby J. Effect of water immersion methods on post-exercise recovery from simulated team sport exercise. J Sci Med Sport 2009; 12: 417-421.
Howatson G, Van Someren KA. Ice massage. Effects on exercise-induced muscle damage. J Sports Med Phys Fitness 2003; 43: 500-505.
Howatson G, Gaze D, van Someren KA. The efficacy of ice massage in the treatment of exercise-induced muscle damage. Scand J Med Sci Sports 2005; 15: 416-422.
Hohenauer E, Costello JT, Stoop R, Kung UM, Clarys P, Deliens T, et al. Cold-water or partial-body cryotherapy? Comparison of physiological responses and recovery following muscle damage. Scand J Med Sci Sports 2018; 28: 1252-1262.
Hohenauer E, Costello JT, Deliens T, Clarys P, Stoop R, Clijsen R. Partial-body cryotherapy (-135 degrees C) and cold-water immersion (10 degrees C) after muscle damage in females. Scand J Med Sci Sports 2020; 30: 485-495.
Higgins TR, Climstein M, Cameron M. Evaluation of hydrotherapy, using passive tests and power tests, for recovery across a cyclic week of competitive rugby union. J Strength Cond Res 2013; 27: 954-965.
Glasgow PD, Ferris R, Bleakley CM. Cold water immersion in the management of delayed-onset muscle soreness: is dose important? A randomised controlled trial. Phys Ther Sport 2014; 15: 228-233.
French DN, Thompson KG, Garland SW, Barnes CA, Portas MD, Hood PE, et al. The effects of contrast bathing and compression therapy on muscular performance. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2008; 40: 1297-1306.
Fonseca LB, Brito CJ, Silva RJ, Silva-Grigoletto ME, da Silva WMJ, Franchini E. Use of Cold-water immersion to reduce muscle damage and delayed-onset muscle soreness and preserve muscle power in jiu-jitsu athletes. J Athl Train 2016; 51: 540-549.
Fonda B, Sarabon N. Effects of whole-body cryotherapy on recovery after hamstring damaging exercise: a crossover study. Scand J Med Sci Sports 2013; 23: e270-278.
Ferreira-Junior JB, Bottaro M, Vieira A, Siqueira AF, Vieira CA, Durigan JL, et al. One session of partial-body cryotherapy (-110 degrees C) improves muscle damage recovery. Scand J Med Sci Sports 2015; 25: e524-530.
Eston R, Peters D. Effects of cold water immersion on the symptoms of exercise-induced muscle damage. J Sports Sci 1999; 17: 231-238.
Elias GP, Wyckelsma VL, Varley MC, McKenna MJ, Aughey RJ. Effectiveness of water immersion on postmatch recovery in elite professional footballers. Int J Sport Physiol Perform 2013; 8: 243-253.
Elias GP, Varley MC, Wyckelsma VL, McKenna MJ, Minahan CL, Aughey RJ. Effects of water immersion on posttraining recovery in Australian footballers. Int J Sport Physiol Perform 2012; 7: 357-366.
Doungkulsa A, Paungmali A, Henry Joseph L, Khamwong P. Effectiveness of air pulsed cryotherapy on delayed onset muscle soreness of elbow flexors following eccentric exercise. Polish Annals Med 2018; 25: 103-111.
Doeringer JR, Colas M, Peacock C, Gatens DR. The effects of postexercise cooling on muscle performance and soreness perception. Athl Ther Today 2018; 23: 73-76.
de Paiva PR, Tomazoni SS, Johnson DS, Vanin AA, Albuquerque-Pontes GM, Machado CD, et al. Photobiomodulation therapy (PBMT) and/or cryotherapy in skeletal muscle restitution, what is better? A randomized, double-blinded, placebo-controlled clinical trial. Laser Med Sci 2016; 31: 1925-1933.
de Freitas VH, Ramos SP, Bara-Filho MG, Freitas DGS, Coimbra DR, Cecchini R, et al. Effect of cold water immersion performed on successive days on physical performance, muscle damage, and inflammatory, hormonal, and oxidative stress markers in volleyball players. J Strength Cond Res 2019; 33: 502-513.
Dantas G, Barros A, Silva B, Belém L, Ferreira V, Fonseca A, et al. Cold-water immersion does not accelerate performance recovery after 10-km street run: randomized controlled clinical trial. Res Q Exerc Sport 2019; 91: 228-238.
Crystal NJ, Townson DH, Cook SB, LaRoche DP. Effect of cryotherapy on muscle recovery and inflammation following a bout of damaging exercise. Eur J Appl Physiol 2013; 113: 2577-2586.
Clifford T, Abbott W, Kwiecien SY, Howatson G, McHugh MP. Cryotherapy reinvented: application of phase change material for recovery in elite soccer. Int J Sport Physiol Perform 2018; 13: 584-589.
Ciccone CD, Leggin BG, Callamaro JJ. Effects of ultrasound and trolamine salicylate phonophoresis on delayed-onset muscle soreness. Phys Ther 1991; 71: 666-675.
Brukner P, Sellwood K, Williams D, Nicol A, Hinman R. Ice water immersion and delayed onset muscle soreness: a randomised controlled trial. Med Sci Sports Exerc 2005; 37: S276-S276.
Bouzid MA, Ghattassi K, Daab W, Zarzissi S, Bouchiba M, Masmoudi L, et al. Faster physical performance recovery with cold water immersion is not related to lower muscle damage level in professional soccer players. J Therm Biol 2018; 78: 184-191.
Behringer M, Jedlicka D, Mester J. Effects of lymphatic drainage and cryotherapy on indirect markers of muscle damage. J Sports Med Phys Fitness 2018; 58: 903-909.
Bailey DM, Erith SJ, Griffin PJ, Dowson A, Brewer DS, Gant N, et al. Influence of cold-water immersion on indices of muscle damage following prolonged intermittent shuttle running. J Sports Sci 2007; 25: 1163-1170.
Aytar A, Tuzun EH, Eker L, Yuruk ZOB, Daskapan A, Akman MN. Effectiveness of low-dose pulsed ultrasound for treatment of delayed-onset muscle soreness: a double-blind randomized controlled trial. Isokinet Exerc Sci 2008; 16: 239-247.
Ascensao A, Leite M, Rebelo AN, Magalhaes S, Magalhaes J. Effects of cold water immersion on the recovery of physical performance and muscle damage following a one-off soccer match. J Sports Sci 2011; 29: 217-225.
Adamczyk JG, Krasowska I, Boguszewski D, Reaburn P. The use of thermal imaging to assess the effectiveness of ice massage and cold-water immersion as methods for supporting post-exercise recovery. J Therm Biol 2016; 60: 20-25.
Abaidia AE, Lamblin J, Delecroix B, Leduc C, McCall A, Nedelec M, et al. Recovery from exercise-induced muscle damage: cold-water immersion versus whole-body cryotherapy. Int J Sports Physiol Perform 2017; 12: 402-409.
Hausswirth C, Louis J, Bieuzen F, Pournot H, Fournier J, Filliard JR, et al. Effects of whole-body cryotherapy vs. far-infrared vs. passive modalities on recovery from exercise-induced muscle damage in highly-trained runners. PLoS One 2011; 6: e277749.
Barber S, Pattison J, Brown F, Hill J. Efficacy of repeated cold water immersion on recovery after a simulated rugby union protocol. J Strength Cond Res 2020; 34: 3523-3529.
Kositsky A, Avela J. The effects of cold water immersion on the recovery of drop jump performance and mechanics: a pilot study in under-20 soccer players. Front Sports Act Living 2020; 2: 17.
Dantas G, Barros A, Silva B, Belém L, Ferreira V, Fonseca A, et al. Cold water immersion does not accelerate performance recovery after 10-km street run. Res Q Exerc Sport 2020; 91: 228-238.
French SD, Cameron M, Walker BF, Esterman AJ. Superficial heat or cold for low back pain. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2006: CD004750.
Costello JT, Baker PR, Minett GM, Bieuzen F, Stewart IB, Bleakley C. Cochrane review: whole-body cryotherapy (extreme cold air exposure) for preventing and treating muscle soreness after exercise in adults. J Evid Based Med 2016; 9: 43-44.
Bleakley C, McDonough S, Gardner E, Baxter GD, Hopkins JT, Davison GW. Cold-water immersion (cryotherapy) for preventing and treating muscle soreness after exercise. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 2012: CD008262.
Banfi G, Lombardi G, Colombini A, Melegati G. Whole-body cryotherapy in athletes. Sports Med 2010; 40: 509-517.
Reinertsen RE, Faerevik H, Holbo K. Optimizing the performance of phase-change materials in personal protective clothing systems. Int J Occup Saf Ergon 2008; 14: 43-53.
Kwiecien SY, McHugh MP, Howatson G. The efficacy of cooling with phase change material for the treatment of exercise-induced muscle damage: pilot study. J Sport Sci 2018; 36: 407-413.
Higgins TR, Greene DA, Baker MK. Effects of cold water immersion and contrast water therapy for recovery from team sport: a systematic review and meta-analysis. J Strength Cond Res 2017; 31: 1443-1460.
Bieuzen F, Bleakley CM, Costello JT. Contrast water therapy and exercise induced muscle damage: a systematic review and meta-analysis. PLoS One 2013; 8: e62356.
Cochrane DJ. Alternating hot and cold water immersion for athlete recovery: a review. Phys Ther Sport 2004; 5: 26-32.
Wood L, Egger M, Gluud LL, Schulz KF, Juni P, Altman DG, et al. Empirical evidence of bias in treatment effect estimates in controlled trials with different interventions and outcomes: meta-epidemiological study. BMJ 2008; 336: 601-605.
How to Cite
Copyright (c) 2021 Yutan Wang, Hongmei Lu, Sijun Li, Yuanyuan Zhang, Fanghong Yan, Yanan Huang, Xiaoli Chen, Ailing Yang, Lin Han, Yuxia Ma
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), allowing third parties to copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format and to remix, transform, and build upon the material for non-commercial purposes, provided proper attribution to the original work.